Monday, August 9, 2010

The Jewish (?) month of Tammuz

The Sumerian King List and the Jewish Connection (?):

After Lugalbanda comes Dumuzi, who was a “major figure in a Sumerian “holy-marriage rite” and “dying-god” myth. Kramer suggests that the Hebrew month of Tammuz is derived from the name of this King and it was this that the prophet Ezekiel (8: 14) was shocked at the women of Jerusalem who were still lamenting his death in the 6th century B.C. Furthermore, the 17th day of the month which bears his name and the lamenting and fasting which is characteristic of this day is also suggested to go back to Sumerian past! (Kramer, 1971, p. 45).

Whilst I have not found any evidence within the works of our sages to corroborate this suggestion regarding the 17th of Tammuz, the biblical commentaries on the aforementioned verse in Ezekiel (8: 14) highlight the significance of the 1st of Tammuz in relation to idolatrous practice. The verse states:

וַיָּבֵא אֹתִי אֶל פֶּתַח שַׁעַר בֵּית יְדוָד אֲשֶׁר אֶל הַצָּפוֹנָה וְהִנֵּה שָׁם הַנָּשִׁים ישְׁבוֹת מְבַכּוֹת אֶת הַתַּמּוּז

(Then He brought me to the door of the gate of the LORD'S house which was toward the north; and, behold, there sat the women weeping for Tammuz)

Rashi, , Radak, Malbim and Metzudos David all comment that Tammuz was the name of a type of idol which appeared to weep with tears due to the heat. Most notably, the Radak and the Malbim quote Maimonides’ elucidation of this practice which is to be found in the “Guide” (Section 3, Ch. 29 ). There Maimonides states:

“In that book the following story is also related (On the Nabatean Agriculture, translated by Ibn Wahshiya): One of the idolatrous prophets, named Tammuz, called upon the king to worship the seven planets and the twelve constellations of the Zodiac: whereupon the king killed him in a dreadful manner. The night of his death the images from all parts of the land came together in the temple of Babylon which was devoted to the image of the Sun, the great golden image. This image, which was suspended between heaven and earth, came down into the midst of the temple, and surrounded by all other images commenced to mourn for Tammuz, and to relate what had befallen him. All other images cried and mourned the whole night; at dawn they flew away and returned to their temples in every corner of the earth. Hence the regular custom arose for the women to weep, lament, mourn, and cry for Tammuz on the first day of the month of Tammuz.”( Guide for the Perplexed, by Moses Maimonides, Friedländer tr. 1904)

Maimonides warns that the fables found in this book are replete with absurdities of idolatrous practice and one should not be misled by them, however he does not deny that these practices were indeed performed.

That which needs to be researched further is whether the use of the Jewish month of Tammuz can actually be attributed to this idol, as Kramer suggests, a concept which would be quite strange, for why would the Jewish people give a name to a month which has such connotations anathema to Torah observance? How the Jewish months were named, who named them and whether they have any relationship with the cultures of their time can also be included in further investigation.

Intro to the Sumerian Civilization

According to Samuel Noah Kramer, until the middle of the 19th century no one knew that “a Sumerian people and language had ever existed”! The Sumerians preceded the Semitic inhabitants of Assyria and Babylonia and it is suggested that it was they who invented the cuneiform system of writing, which had previously been attributed to the Semitic inhabitants of Assyria and Babylonia. The name “Sumerian” is attributed to Jules Oppert in 1869 which was based upon many inscriptions found of the early rulers titled “ King of Sumer and Akkad” (p.21). Over the next century, archeological excavations were carried out at certain sites within Iraq, such as Nippur, Lagash, Fara (ancient Shuruppak), Bismaya, Kish, Waka (also known as Uruk by Sumerians and Akkadians and Erech in the Bible), Ur (or Urim acc. To Sumerians), and al Ubaid.

Kramer informs us that the two important dates for Sumerian chronology are the end of the 3rd dynasty of Ur, “where the Sumerians lost their predominant political position in Mesopotamia and the beginning of the reign of the Hammurabi of Babylon”. These dates are approximately 1945 B.C. (the beginning of the decline) and 1750 B.C. (the takeover). There is enough conclusive archeological evidence to suggest that the Sumerian civilization dates back to 2500 B.C, however any further back than this, Kramer cautions, that it is dependent upon “archeological, stratigraphic, epigraphic inferences and the results of carbon-14 tests” which are not as conclusive as what was originally anticipated.

The Sumerians: Their History, Culture & Character by Noah Samuel Kramer

I recently picked up a book on the Sumerians entitled “The Sumerians: Their History, Culture & Character” by Noah Samuel Kramer.

One of the reasons why I decided to start reading this obscure book was that I had heard of the Sumerians, however had known absolutely nothing about them except that they were an ancient civilization that inhabited some area of the Middle East. Secondly, I feel that by coming to understand the sociological, religious, cultural, historical etc, impact of a major civilization particularly (although not limited to) in this region, it would help me to gain a more holistic view and understanding of the context and environment within which our forefathers and the Jewish religion were surrounded. Tracking the paths of history from beginning to end, from near and far, can allow one to view the entire process as one complex organism and allows for greater understanding of the influences and stimuli that characterize who we are today. The Jewish religion primarily lays claim to a Divine influence and transmission of text and tradition, and these observations are in no way an attempt to overlook that, however, how we choose to transmit this knowledge through particular language, practice and concepts can not be assumed to be impervious to external influence (even if it is merely the external husk alone). For myself, this is an attempt to contextualize – therefore one of my aims is also to create a timeline of Jewish History parallel to these ancient civilizations.

I will begin by giving an overview of some interesting aspects of the Sumerian culture as found in Kramer’s “The Sumerians” (1971), and hope to continue by noting any Jewish parallels of biblical references as well. This should not be assumed to be comprehensive and authoritative, rather an introduction.

Monday, July 26, 2010

Shabbos Nachamu and Vaeschanan

This shiur was given at the Young Israel of East Northport on Thursday, July 22nd, 2010.

Parshas Devarim: 9th Av, Laws, Background and Eichah

This Shiur was given at the Young Israel of East Northport on Thursday July 15th, 2010.

Matos-Masei

This shiur was given at the Young Israel of East Northport on Thursday, July 8th, 2010.

Parshas Pinchas

This shiur was given at the Young Israel of East Northport on Thursday, July 1st, 2010.